Certified in Risk and Information Systems Control CRISC Practice Test 56
Question 550
A vendor has certified controls but the outsourced business process remains outside tolerance. The organization has taken steps to escalate the residual exposure for response regardless of assurance badges. Which test finding would most clearly show the intended control outcome?
- Risk owner documents what exposure remains despite contractual allocation
- Risk owner decision addresses the measured gap against tolerance
- Assessment shows how measured detection affects residual fraud loss
- Recovery tests and BIA link backup performance to residual exposure
Explanation
Correct Answer
B:The observed result provides relevant operating evidence rather than relying on an untested claim. Attestations do not automatically bring business risk within appetite.
Incorrect Answers
A:Risk owner documents what exposure remains despite contractual allocation. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is risk owner decision addresses the measured gap against tolerance. The control being tested is to escalate the residual exposure for response regardless of assurance badges.
C:Assessment shows how measured detection affects residual fraud loss. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is risk owner decision addresses the measured gap against tolerance. The control being tested is to escalate the residual exposure for response regardless of assurance badges.
D:Recovery tests and BIA link backup performance to residual exposure. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is risk owner decision addresses the measured gap against tolerance. The control being tested is to escalate the residual exposure for response regardless of assurance badges.
Question 551
An energy utility's board prioritizes decarbonization using connected field devices. The organization has taken steps to define cyber-physical risk scenarios that could prevent emissions and grid targets. Which test finding would most clearly show the intended control outcome?
- Clinical owners approve safety-impact tiers and the linked system risk priorities
- Partner onboarding evidence shows mapped subscriber and billing failure paths
- Risk owners confirm scenarios involving field availability and grid safety
- Finance and product owners approve payout loss and settlement exposure models
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:This tests whether the chosen response is working: risk owners confirm scenarios involving field availability and grid safety. Business outcomes include operational safety, not only data protection.
Incorrect Answers
A:Clinical owners approve safety-impact tiers and the linked system risk priorities. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is risk owners confirm scenarios involving field availability and grid safety. The control being tested is to define cyber-physical risk scenarios that could prevent emissions and grid targets.
B:Partner onboarding evidence shows mapped subscriber and billing failure paths. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is risk owners confirm scenarios involving field availability and grid safety. The control being tested is to define cyber-physical risk scenarios that could prevent emissions and grid targets.
D:Finance and product owners approve payout loss and settlement exposure models. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is risk owners confirm scenarios involving field availability and grid safety. The control being tested is to define cyber-physical risk scenarios that could prevent emissions and grid targets.
Question 552
A security engineer can both request and approve privileged production access. The organization has taken steps to separate request, authorization and provisioning duties for sensitive access. Which test finding would most clearly show the intended control outcome?
- Classification approvals are traceable to accountable information owners
- Acceptance records are approved by roles whose delegations cover assessed exposure
- A current RACI and exception log identify the approver for each renewal
- Approved workflows show distinct requester, approver and fulfiller identities
Explanation
Correct Answer
D:The proposed observation checks the exact control result, not merely a plan or assertion. Conflicting duties create opportunity for unauthorized self-approval.
Incorrect Answers
A:Classification approvals are traceable to accountable information owners. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is approved workflows show distinct requester, approver and fulfiller identities. The control being tested is to separate request, authorization and provisioning duties for sensitive access.
B:Acceptance records are approved by roles whose delegations cover assessed exposure. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is approved workflows show distinct requester, approver and fulfiller identities. The control being tested is to separate request, authorization and provisioning duties for sensitive access.
C:A current RACI and exception log identify the approver for each renewal. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is approved workflows show distinct requester, approver and fulfiller identities. The control being tested is to separate request, authorization and provisioning duties for sensitive access.
Question 553
A diversified group double-counts one shared identity provider risk in ten subsidiaries. The organization has taken steps to map risk dependencies and consolidate shared exposure without losing local impacts. Which test finding would most clearly show the intended control outcome?
- ERM rollups distinguish common failure drivers from subsidiary-specific impacts
- Investment maps connect top risks, business objectives and funded responses
- Portfolio reviews identify common failure causes and possible combined exposure
- Investment cases compare groupwide exposures and treatment benefits
Explanation
Correct Answer
A:That evidence tests the case-specific outcome of the adopted change. Shared events should not be misrepresented as independent losses.
Incorrect Answers
B:Investment maps connect top risks, business objectives and funded responses. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is ERM rollups distinguish common failure drivers from subsidiary-specific impacts. The control being tested is to map risk dependencies and consolidate shared exposure without losing local impacts.
C:Portfolio reviews identify common failure causes and possible combined exposure. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is ERM rollups distinguish common failure drivers from subsidiary-specific impacts. The control being tested is to map risk dependencies and consolidate shared exposure without losing local impacts.
D:Investment cases compare groupwide exposures and treatment benefits. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is ERM rollups distinguish common failure drivers from subsidiary-specific impacts. The control being tested is to map risk dependencies and consolidate shared exposure without losing local impacts.
Question 554
An executive repeatedly receives a special exception from travel data-handling rules. The organization has taken steps to apply consistently approved exceptions and visibly hold senior leaders to standards. Which test finding would most clearly show the intended control outcome?
- Sales reviews include verified policy adherence alongside conversion outcomes
- Exception logs show consistent thresholds and accountable executive approval
- Workers correctly handle role-specific scenarios during observed exercises
- Approved workflow times drop and shadow data storage findings decline
Explanation
Correct Answer
B:The observed result provides relevant operating evidence rather than relying on an untested claim. Perceived double standards erode a risk-aware culture.
Incorrect Answers
A:Sales reviews include verified policy adherence alongside conversion outcomes. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is exception logs show consistent thresholds and accountable executive approval. The control being tested is to apply consistently approved exceptions and visibly hold senior leaders to standards.
C:Workers correctly handle role-specific scenarios during observed exercises. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is exception logs show consistent thresholds and accountable executive approval. The control being tested is to apply consistently approved exceptions and visibly hold senior leaders to standards.
D:Approved workflow times drop and shadow data storage findings decline. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is exception logs show consistent thresholds and accountable executive approval. The control being tested is to apply consistently approved exceptions and visibly hold senior leaders to standards.
Question 555
A security assessor both implements a firewall rule and signs its independent assurance report. The organization has taken steps to separate implementation from independent assessment for the material rule set. Which test finding would most clearly show the intended control outcome?
- Risk oversight reviews actual operating metrics and records challenges
- Audit committee receives independent scope, findings and follow-up reports
- Evidence shows rule implementers did not perform sole independent validation
- Governance minutes show management decisions with audit in assurance role
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:This tests whether the chosen response is working: evidence shows rule implementers did not perform sole independent validation. Review independence matters when testing one's own work.
Incorrect Answers
A:Risk oversight reviews actual operating metrics and records challenges. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is evidence shows rule implementers did not perform sole independent validation. The control being tested is to separate implementation from independent assessment for the material rule set.
B:Audit committee receives independent scope, findings and follow-up reports. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is evidence shows rule implementers did not perform sole independent validation. The control being tested is to separate implementation from independent assessment for the material rule set.
D:Governance minutes show management decisions with audit in assurance role. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is evidence shows rule implementers did not perform sole independent validation. The control being tested is to separate implementation from independent assessment for the material rule set.
Question 556
A workforce policy covers laptops but excludes newly deployed shared tablets. The organization has taken steps to revise the asset-use standard to cover the actual endpoint inventory. Which test finding would most clearly show the intended control outcome?
- Approved tool guidance and tests prevent uploads of restricted data
- Policy revisions and retention standards cite the same approved record schedules
- Incident exercises follow the approved workflow and capture documented deviations
- Sample tablet configurations meet the newly approved baseline
Explanation
Correct Answer
D:The proposed observation checks the exact control result, not merely a plan or assertion. Requirements should reflect the assets actually used.
Incorrect Answers
A:Approved tool guidance and tests prevent uploads of restricted data. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is sample tablet configurations meet the newly approved baseline. The control being tested is to revise the asset-use standard to cover the actual endpoint inventory.
B:Policy revisions and retention standards cite the same approved record schedules. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is sample tablet configurations meet the newly approved baseline. The control being tested is to revise the asset-use standard to cover the actual endpoint inventory.
C:Incident exercises follow the approved workflow and capture documented deviations. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is sample tablet configurations meet the newly approved baseline. The control being tested is to revise the asset-use standard to cover the actual endpoint inventory.
Question 557
A manufacturer has no trend information for its top production cyber risks. The organization has taken steps to track directional changes and treatment progress in its profile. Which test finding would most clearly show the intended control outcome?
- Quarterly risk profile shows changes in likelihood, impact and residual exposure
- Risk profile analysis links common supplier failure to multiple business impacts
- Profile review identifies the cloud concentration and response owner
- Risk profile connects the scenario to outages, recovery constraints and owners
Explanation
Correct Answer
A:That evidence tests the case-specific outcome of the adopted change. Profiles should support timing and priority decisions.
Incorrect Answers
B:Risk profile analysis links common supplier failure to multiple business impacts. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is quarterly risk profile shows changes in likelihood, impact and residual exposure. The control being tested is to track directional changes and treatment progress in its profile.
C:Profile review identifies the cloud concentration and response owner. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is quarterly risk profile shows changes in likelihood, impact and residual exposure. The control being tested is to track directional changes and treatment progress in its profile.
D:Risk profile connects the scenario to outages, recovery constraints and owners. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is quarterly risk profile shows changes in likelihood, impact and residual exposure. The control being tested is to track directional changes and treatment progress in its profile.
Question 558
A manufacturer has no documented dependency on its sole packaging-material provider. The organization has taken steps to include supplier interruption scenarios in enterprise continuity planning. Which test finding would most clearly show the intended control outcome?
- Change approvals reference admissions surge and tested alternate capacity
- BCP exercises demonstrate alternate packaging supply within business tolerance
- Business impact records cover new stores and exercises include their systems
- Exercises demonstrate manual dispatch and reconciliation without live servers
Explanation
Correct Answer
B:The observed result provides relevant operating evidence rather than relying on an untested claim. Critical process dependencies extend outside owned technology.
Incorrect Answers
A:Change approvals reference admissions surge and tested alternate capacity. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is BCP exercises demonstrate alternate packaging supply within business tolerance. The control being tested is to include supplier interruption scenarios in enterprise continuity planning.
C:Business impact records cover new stores and exercises include their systems. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is BCP exercises demonstrate alternate packaging supply within business tolerance. The control being tested is to include supplier interruption scenarios in enterprise continuity planning.
D:Exercises demonstrate manual dispatch and reconciliation without live servers. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is BCP exercises demonstrate alternate packaging supply within business tolerance. The control being tested is to include supplier interruption scenarios in enterprise continuity planning.
Question 559
A hospital wants to accept possible life-safety harm using a routine IT help-desk waiver. The organization has taken steps to escalate according to safety-critical appetite and authority constraints. Which test finding would most clearly show the intended control outcome?
- Governance minutes document retained or revised limits with economic rationale
- Board-authorized appetite statement covers relevant technology risk categories
- Approvals follow clinical safety governance instead of routine IT waivers
- Risk assessment highlights rare catastrophic loss relative to capacity
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:This tests whether the chosen response is working: approvals follow clinical safety governance instead of routine IT waivers. Certain impacts require much higher acceptance authority.
Incorrect Answers
A:Governance minutes document retained or revised limits with economic rationale. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is approvals follow clinical safety governance instead of routine IT waivers. The control being tested is to escalate according to safety-critical appetite and authority constraints.
B:Board-authorized appetite statement covers relevant technology risk categories. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is approvals follow clinical safety governance instead of routine IT waivers. The control being tested is to escalate according to safety-critical appetite and authority constraints.
D:Risk assessment highlights rare catastrophic loss relative to capacity. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is approvals follow clinical safety governance instead of routine IT waivers. The control being tested is to escalate according to safety-critical appetite and authority constraints.
Question 560
A utility does not classify remote substations by safety impact. The organization has taken steps to use business and operational impact to classify critical infrastructure assets. Which test finding would most clearly show the intended control outcome?
- Validated OT inventory records firmware, network paths and operational criticality
- Asset register flags unsupported software before approved replacement dates
- Priority queues reflect critical production assets and justified risk ratings
- Approved classifications distinguish safety-critical field devices from office tools
Explanation
Correct Answer
D:The proposed observation checks the exact control result, not merely a plan or assertion. Asset criticality should guide control effort.
Incorrect Answers
A:Validated OT inventory records firmware, network paths and operational criticality. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is approved classifications distinguish safety-critical field devices from office tools. The control being tested is to use business and operational impact to classify critical infrastructure assets.
B:Asset register flags unsupported software before approved replacement dates. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is approved classifications distinguish safety-critical field devices from office tools. The control being tested is to use business and operational impact to classify critical infrastructure assets.
C:Priority queues reflect critical production assets and justified risk ratings. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is approved classifications distinguish safety-critical field devices from office tools. The control being tested is to use business and operational impact to classify critical infrastructure assets.