Certified in Risk and Information Systems Control CRISC Practice Test 38
Question 370
A supplier risk entry has no update since the supplier's acquisition by another group. Management reports it has begun to trigger a reassessment and record changed ownership and exposure assumptions. Which review finding would BEST substantiate the control outcome?
- Audit trail shows old/new ratings, source evidence and reviewer
- Register update captures the supplier change, new rating and action owner
- Consolidated reporting avoids duplicate and orphaned material exposures
- Register distinguishes acceptance authority from action assignees
Explanation
Correct Answer
B:The proposed observation checks the exact control result, not merely a plan or assertion. Risk records must reflect material environmental change.
Incorrect Answers
A:Audit trail shows old/new ratings, source evidence and reviewer. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is register update captures the supplier change, new rating and action owner. The control being tested is to trigger a reassessment and record changed ownership and exposure assumptions.
C:Consolidated reporting avoids duplicate and orphaned material exposures. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is register update captures the supplier change, new rating and action owner. The control being tested is to trigger a reassessment and record changed ownership and exposure assumptions.
D:Register distinguishes acceptance authority from action assignees. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is register update captures the supplier change, new rating and action owner. The control being tested is to trigger a reassessment and record changed ownership and exposure assumptions.
Question 371
A hospital assesses rare but severe ransomware consequences using average downtime alone. Management reports it has begun to include plausible catastrophic-tail scenarios and impact ranges. Which review finding would BEST substantiate the control outcome?
- Assessment includes assumptions and ranges for data-poor scenarios
- Reported expected loss includes inputs, units and uncertainty ranges
- Results show severe service-loss tails alongside central estimates
- Analysis reveals nonlinear losses around the four-hour threshold
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:That evidence tests the case-specific outcome of the adopted change. Mean outcomes can hide unacceptable safety consequences.
Incorrect Answers
A:Assessment includes assumptions and ranges for data-poor scenarios. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is results show severe service-loss tails alongside central estimates. The control being tested is to include plausible catastrophic-tail scenarios and impact ranges.
B:Reported expected loss includes inputs, units and uncertainty ranges. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is results show severe service-loss tails alongside central estimates. The control being tested is to include plausible catastrophic-tail scenarios and impact ranges.
D:Analysis reveals nonlinear losses around the four-hour threshold. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is results show severe service-loss tails alongside central estimates. The control being tested is to include plausible catastrophic-tail scenarios and impact ranges.
Question 372
A patching control repeatedly fails because IT and application teams dispute ownership. Management reports it has begun to assign accountable patch decision rights and implementation responsibility for each platform. Which review finding would BEST substantiate the control outcome?
- Control charter names an operator and separate audit testing mandate
- Clinical governance record and contract define separate accountabilities
- Responsibility matrix matches contract duties and cloud configurations
- Asset-to-owner mapping and closure reports cover previously orphaned systems
Explanation
Correct Answer
D:The observed result provides relevant operating evidence rather than relying on an untested claim. Unclear control ownership creates persistent gaps.
Incorrect Answers
A:Control charter names an operator and separate audit testing mandate. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is asset-to-owner mapping and closure reports cover previously orphaned systems. The control being tested is to assign accountable patch decision rights and implementation responsibility for each platform.
B:Clinical governance record and contract define separate accountabilities. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is asset-to-owner mapping and closure reports cover previously orphaned systems. The control being tested is to assign accountable patch decision rights and implementation responsibility for each platform.
C:Responsibility matrix matches contract duties and cloud configurations. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is asset-to-owner mapping and closure reports cover previously orphaned systems. The control being tested is to assign accountable patch decision rights and implementation responsibility for each platform.
Question 373
A hospital's security framework applies generic enterprise rules to safety-critical medical devices. Management reports it has begun to tailor the baseline using clinical safety and operational constraints. Which review finding would BEST substantiate the control outcome?
- Control mapping records applicable safety requirements and verified compensating safeguards
- Adoption review demonstrates risk reduction rather than a raw control count
- Retention policy and sampled hold records preserve legally required data
- Threat scenarios map privileged misuse to preventive and detective safeguards
Explanation
Correct Answer
A:This tests whether the chosen response is working: control mapping records applicable safety requirements and verified compensating safeguards. Frameworks need risk-sensitive implementation context.
Incorrect Answers
B:Adoption review demonstrates risk reduction rather than a raw control count. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is control mapping records applicable safety requirements and verified compensating safeguards. The control being tested is to tailor the baseline using clinical safety and operational constraints.
C:Retention policy and sampled hold records preserve legally required data. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is control mapping records applicable safety requirements and verified compensating safeguards. The control being tested is to tailor the baseline using clinical safety and operational constraints.
D:Threat scenarios map privileged misuse to preventive and detective safeguards. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is control mapping records applicable safety requirements and verified compensating safeguards. The control being tested is to tailor the baseline using clinical safety and operational constraints.
Question 374
A bank has accepted residual outage risk but a recent failover test now fails. Management reports it has begun to increase residual exposure estimates and escalate the changed position. Which review finding would BEST substantiate the control outcome?
- Residual model accounts for shared dependencies and combined failure
- Revised risk rating cites failover failure and compares it with appetite
- Assessment shows consistent criteria for the before and after ratings
- Risk analysis reflects plausible incidents and time-to-detect evidence
Explanation
Correct Answer
B:The proposed observation checks the exact control result, not merely a plan or assertion. Evidence of a failed control invalidates prior residual assumptions.
Incorrect Answers
A:Residual model accounts for shared dependencies and combined failure. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is revised risk rating cites failover failure and compares it with appetite. The control being tested is to increase residual exposure estimates and escalate the changed position.
C:Assessment shows consistent criteria for the before and after ratings. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is revised risk rating cites failover failure and compares it with appetite. The control being tested is to increase residual exposure estimates and escalate the changed position.
D:Risk analysis reflects plausible incidents and time-to-detect evidence. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is revised risk rating cites failover failure and compares it with appetite. The control being tested is to increase residual exposure estimates and escalate the changed position.
Question 375
A university plans to monetize alumni analytics while its risk register covers only teaching systems. Management reports it has begun to bring the analytics business objective and data-use constraints into risk planning. Which review finding would BEST substantiate the control outcome?
- The approved strategy risk map includes impersonation and accessibility outcomes
- A risk-to-strategy traceability review includes contractor access and service continuity
- Risk planning documents both revenue outcomes and privacy-related failure effects
- Product owners approve metrics for erroneous denials and delayed claims
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:That evidence tests the case-specific outcome of the adopted change. New strategic objectives bring new value and new constraints.
Incorrect Answers
A:The approved strategy risk map includes impersonation and accessibility outcomes. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is risk planning documents both revenue outcomes and privacy-related failure effects. The control being tested is to bring the analytics business objective and data-use constraints into risk planning.
B:A risk-to-strategy traceability review includes contractor access and service continuity. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is risk planning documents both revenue outcomes and privacy-related failure effects. The control being tested is to bring the analytics business objective and data-use constraints into risk planning.
D:Product owners approve metrics for erroneous denials and delayed claims. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is risk planning documents both revenue outcomes and privacy-related failure effects. The control being tested is to bring the analytics business objective and data-use constraints into risk planning.
Question 376
A hospital purchases a managed records system and assumes its supplier owns patient risk. Management reports it has begun to retain a hospital business risk owner while assigning vendor control obligations. Which review finding would BEST substantiate the control outcome?
- Incident playbooks and simulations demonstrate authorized rollback decisions
- The merged risk delegation charter names one accountable business decision role
- Finding records include assigned owners, deadlines and acceptance criteria
- Contracts and risk records identify both hospital risk ownership and vendor duties
Explanation
Correct Answer
D:The observed result provides relevant operating evidence rather than relying on an untested claim. A service contract cannot transfer organizational accountability.
Incorrect Answers
A:Incident playbooks and simulations demonstrate authorized rollback decisions. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is contracts and risk records identify both hospital risk ownership and vendor duties. The control being tested is to retain a hospital business risk owner while assigning vendor control obligations.
B:The merged risk delegation charter names one accountable business decision role. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is contracts and risk records identify both hospital risk ownership and vendor duties. The control being tested is to retain a hospital business risk owner while assigning vendor control obligations.
C:Finding records include assigned owners, deadlines and acceptance criteria. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is contracts and risk records identify both hospital risk ownership and vendor duties. The control being tested is to retain a hospital business risk owner while assigning vendor control obligations.
Question 377
A cloud migration risk is tracked only by developers, not in the enterprise risk system. Management reports it has begun to link material project risks to enterprise ERM reporting and ownership. Which review finding would BEST substantiate the control outcome?
- The ERM register includes cloud migration exposure with named business owner
- Risk-mapping tables link previous categories to enterprise definitions
- Acceptance records show common authority thresholds across units
- Cross-functional calibration sessions produce reproducible enterprise ratings
Explanation
Correct Answer
A:This tests whether the chosen response is working: the ERM register includes cloud migration exposure with named business owner. Material exposure should not remain inside a project silo.
Incorrect Answers
B:Risk-mapping tables link previous categories to enterprise definitions. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is the ERM register includes cloud migration exposure with named business owner. The control being tested is to link material project risks to enterprise ERM reporting and ownership.
C:Acceptance records show common authority thresholds across units. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is the ERM register includes cloud migration exposure with named business owner. The control being tested is to link material project risks to enterprise ERM reporting and ownership.
D:Cross-functional calibration sessions produce reproducible enterprise ratings. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is the ERM register includes cloud migration exposure with named business owner. The control being tested is to link material project risks to enterprise ERM reporting and ownership.
Question 378
A new subsidiary treats privacy reviews as an obstacle that can be ignored. Management reports it has begun to engage local leaders to connect privacy decisions with customer trust outcomes. Which review finding would BEST substantiate the control outcome?
- Payment escalation drills show staff can pause and obtain a timely decision
- Subsidiary leadership routinely sponsors documented privacy risk decisions
- Contractor evaluations and event follow-ups demonstrate consistent conduct standards
- Release records show timely defect disclosure and risk-informed decisions
Explanation
Correct Answer
B:The proposed observation checks the exact control result, not merely a plan or assertion. Culture improves when leaders explain the value of risk-aware behavior.
Incorrect Answers
A:Payment escalation drills show staff can pause and obtain a timely decision. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is subsidiary leadership routinely sponsors documented privacy risk decisions. The control being tested is to engage local leaders to connect privacy decisions with customer trust outcomes.
C:Contractor evaluations and event follow-ups demonstrate consistent conduct standards. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is subsidiary leadership routinely sponsors documented privacy risk decisions. The control being tested is to engage local leaders to connect privacy decisions with customer trust outcomes.
D:Release records show timely defect disclosure and risk-informed decisions. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is subsidiary leadership routinely sponsors documented privacy risk decisions. The control being tested is to engage local leaders to connect privacy decisions with customer trust outcomes.
Question 379
An outsourcing contract leaves no internal person to oversee vendor operating controls. Management reports it has begun to designate a first-line supplier owner and second-line challenge of material exposures. Which review finding would BEST substantiate the control outcome?
- Second-line exceptions and objections are visible to risk governance leadership
- Finding closure evidence is provided by operators and validated independently
- Supplier assessments identify operational ownership plus independent review
- SLA exception rates are checked by an oversight role not operating the service
Explanation
Correct Answer
C:That evidence tests the case-specific outcome of the adopted change. External vendors do not replace internal lines of accountability.
Incorrect Answers
A:Second-line exceptions and objections are visible to risk governance leadership. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is supplier assessments identify operational ownership plus independent review. The control being tested is to designate a first-line supplier owner and second-line challenge of material exposures.
B:Finding closure evidence is provided by operators and validated independently. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is supplier assessments identify operational ownership plus independent review. The control being tested is to designate a first-line supplier owner and second-line challenge of material exposures.
D:SLA exception rates are checked by an oversight role not operating the service. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is supplier assessments identify operational ownership plus independent review. The control being tested is to designate a first-line supplier owner and second-line challenge of material exposures.
Question 380
A division circulates unsigned draft cloud standards as binding requirements. Management reports it has begun to enforce approval, versioning, ownership and controlled publication of standards. Which review finding would BEST substantiate the control outcome?
- Revision history links new legal duties to updated access requirements
- Executed agreements and vendor tests demonstrate the required control clauses
- Standard publication and sampled endpoints demonstrate retirement of the old protocol
- Standard inventory identifies the current effective approved version
Explanation
Correct Answer
D:The observed result provides relevant operating evidence rather than relying on an untested claim. Uncontrolled drafts create inconsistent compliance decisions.
Incorrect Answers
A:Revision history links new legal duties to updated access requirements. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is standard inventory identifies the current effective approved version. The control being tested is to enforce approval, versioning, ownership and controlled publication of standards.
B:Executed agreements and vendor tests demonstrate the required control clauses. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is standard inventory identifies the current effective approved version. The control being tested is to enforce approval, versioning, ownership and controlled publication of standards.
C:Standard publication and sampled endpoints demonstrate retirement of the old protocol. That observation would not prove this risk treatment effective. The matching evidence is standard inventory identifies the current effective approved version. The control being tested is to enforce approval, versioning, ownership and controlled publication of standards.